Yesterday Phil Tonks broadcast his interview with Adrian Shooter. In it, he asked Adrian - a well-known supporter of HS2 - about his views on HS2. Not surprisingly, Adrian said he was in favour and gave two key reasons: first, Evergreen 3 had proved that Chiltern was running to line capacity; and secondly, that HS2 would spin-off economic benefits from London...
I am not a supporter of HS2 and I didn't find Adrian's arguments convincing. Take capacity... one of the weaknesses of Evergreen 3 is that it failed to reinstate the through tracks at stations such as Bicester North, Beaconsfield, and High Wycombe. Indeed, at Bicester North, the Up platform was actually moved rather than install points and a new line (for cost reasons apparently). Already, Chiltern are reaping what they have sown as Mainline trains are delayed by stopping trains failing to get to their refuge sidings as timetabled.
Further north, much of the four track infrastructure between Dorridge and Tyesley still exists, providing further opportunities for capacity improvements. And of course, more could be done at Wembley.
What surprises me most about the capacity argument is the seeming lack of faith in the development of signalling and train control infrastructure. HS2 is a long-term project YET it seems that the rail industry believes that the situation in 2026 will be that of 2011 when it is more than likely that capacity increases will come from leaps forward in signalling technology.
As for the economic argument... Chiltern's own fare structure gives lie to it. To even tempt people in London to travel to Birmingham, the company is forced to price its morning peak trains from Marylebone at £25 return whilst pricing the Birmingham London flow at £75. The reality is that work will flow from Birmingham to London at an even faster rate with HS2 as Birmingham becomes simply a dormitory city to London...
Clearly, I have not got Adrian's 41 year track record of success in the rail industry, but I have got 35 years' experience of working in the UK 'regions'. HS2 is an expensive white elephant of a project which will NOT benefit Birmingham.
Sunday, 11 September 2011
Friday, 9 September 2011
Miscellany
Chiltern are seeking feedback on the Mainline timetable - complete the short survey at http://chilternrailways.co.uk/news/tell-us-what-you-think-about-our-timetable
Chiltern are also co-sponsoring the Style Birmingham Live weekend (24-26 September). Thursday's Birmingham Post has a Makeover competition which includes five Chiltern return tickets in the prize package. Hurry though as the closing date is Monday (12th). Don't forget the Birmingham Fun Day at Moor Street station on Sunday (11th).
Not to be outdone, LondonMidland is sponsoring the Birmingham Food Fest (14-23 October). Not clear what they will be offering though the Birmingham Post has suggested that canapés will be served to commuters (!). What seems to be clear is that it won't involve any on-board catering...
Finally, Virgin are busy reminding everyone that they are still the fastest between Birmingham and London with their 'Retro' campaign. The problem is: they may be the fastest but do they actually offer value for money to their non-railcard holding Standard Class passengers. Planning to find out next Wednesday...
Chiltern are also co-sponsoring the Style Birmingham Live weekend (24-26 September). Thursday's Birmingham Post has a Makeover competition which includes five Chiltern return tickets in the prize package. Hurry though as the closing date is Monday (12th). Don't forget the Birmingham Fun Day at Moor Street station on Sunday (11th).
Not to be outdone, LondonMidland is sponsoring the Birmingham Food Fest (14-23 October). Not clear what they will be offering though the Birmingham Post has suggested that canapés will be served to commuters (!). What seems to be clear is that it won't involve any on-board catering...
Finally, Virgin are busy reminding everyone that they are still the fastest between Birmingham and London with their 'Retro' campaign. The problem is: they may be the fastest but do they actually offer value for money to their non-railcard holding Standard Class passengers. Planning to find out next Wednesday...
Chiltern Railways Mainline Day 4
Yesterday, courtesy of Chiltern's Mainlineforapound promotion, I was able to travel on two of Chiltern's 'nice and fast' services for the princely sum of £2 return. Going up to London, I joined the 0855 from Birmingham Moor Street. Coming back, I was on the 1630 from London Marylebone. Both, of course, are Clubman services.
The 0855 starts as a commuter service from Kidderminster at 0809 and so was reasonably busy on arrival. No problem getting a table seat however, despite the fact that the service was a 3 carriage, rather than 4 carriage, set. As ever, quite a few commuters left at Solihull but London bound passengers joined. Then a flood of people at the last stop before Marylebone - Warwick Parkway - as this is first train on which the £50 return fare (as opposed to the £75 return fare) is valid. Still, no standing passengers.
One of the Mainline enhancements is the provision of free WiFi in Clubmans, to go with the power sockets and tables - in theory making a good working environment. Alas, the WiFi seems to be taking time to bed down on the Clubmans: availability yesterday was erratic, and Chiltern haven't managed to solve the 'black' hole in mobile coverage between Aynho Junction and Bicester North. Nevertheless, some use was possible and I was amused to see Google ask me if I wanted to change to Google.se as it had detected that I was using a Swedish service (Chiltern's WiFi provider hails from there)...
Another enhancement is going to be improved catering trolleys. Alas, yesterday's was an old style one and took an age to traverse the train (having been loaded at Moor Street). In fact, I think that it was as we were passing through High Wycombe that finally a full service had been provided. Still, the prices aren't bad - £1.60 for tea / £2 for coffee - but you don't get a 'pot' on the Clubmans.
Slightly disconcerting to find that the disabled toilet appeared not to be working - in fact, the door lock, though working, was failing to display 'engaged' outside, giving the impression that the door had failed. Still, better than the other way round I suppose.
Arrival into Marylebone was around 5 minutes late (ie 98 rather than the booked 93 mins) as a local train got in the way at Princes Risborough. Overall, though, for a pound, the service can't be faulted!
Coming back, my journey was enlivened by the companionship of a member of the Railway Performance Society who was timing the Clubman run for the logs kept by the Society. One of Chiltern's sources of pride on Mainline is the work done at Northolt Junction to raise the line speed there. My companion wasn't disappointed: the Clubman recording 100mph as it breasted the rise into South Ruislip.
A downside of the improved opportunities for Clubmans (and indeed Silver trains) to show their paces is the inability of the old Turbos to get out of the way as timetabled. Good running was marred at Gerrard's Cross, High Wycombe, and Bicester North by the failure to clear the main line promptly, but then the railways would run alot more smoothly if passengers wouldn't insist on getting off the trains at their stations... Nevertheless it does appear that the Mainline timetable is very tightly planned and thus open to delays very easily.
Alas, my own journey was marred by the failure of the WiFi altogether on this set though at least the power points were working. No catering trolley of course, being an evening service. One wonders how the Silver trains are doing in this respect.
Arrival into Birmingham Moor Street was 4 minutes down (94 mins for the journey as opposed to the booked 90) BUT of course arrival into Snow Hill was on time as the 16.30 is booked to stand for 4 mins at Moor Street!
Lots of quibbles I know but overall Mainline is going to be worth it, I'm sure
The 0855 starts as a commuter service from Kidderminster at 0809 and so was reasonably busy on arrival. No problem getting a table seat however, despite the fact that the service was a 3 carriage, rather than 4 carriage, set. As ever, quite a few commuters left at Solihull but London bound passengers joined. Then a flood of people at the last stop before Marylebone - Warwick Parkway - as this is first train on which the £50 return fare (as opposed to the £75 return fare) is valid. Still, no standing passengers.
One of the Mainline enhancements is the provision of free WiFi in Clubmans, to go with the power sockets and tables - in theory making a good working environment. Alas, the WiFi seems to be taking time to bed down on the Clubmans: availability yesterday was erratic, and Chiltern haven't managed to solve the 'black' hole in mobile coverage between Aynho Junction and Bicester North. Nevertheless, some use was possible and I was amused to see Google ask me if I wanted to change to Google.se as it had detected that I was using a Swedish service (Chiltern's WiFi provider hails from there)...
Another enhancement is going to be improved catering trolleys. Alas, yesterday's was an old style one and took an age to traverse the train (having been loaded at Moor Street). In fact, I think that it was as we were passing through High Wycombe that finally a full service had been provided. Still, the prices aren't bad - £1.60 for tea / £2 for coffee - but you don't get a 'pot' on the Clubmans.
Slightly disconcerting to find that the disabled toilet appeared not to be working - in fact, the door lock, though working, was failing to display 'engaged' outside, giving the impression that the door had failed. Still, better than the other way round I suppose.
Arrival into Marylebone was around 5 minutes late (ie 98 rather than the booked 93 mins) as a local train got in the way at Princes Risborough. Overall, though, for a pound, the service can't be faulted!
Coming back, my journey was enlivened by the companionship of a member of the Railway Performance Society who was timing the Clubman run for the logs kept by the Society. One of Chiltern's sources of pride on Mainline is the work done at Northolt Junction to raise the line speed there. My companion wasn't disappointed: the Clubman recording 100mph as it breasted the rise into South Ruislip.
A downside of the improved opportunities for Clubmans (and indeed Silver trains) to show their paces is the inability of the old Turbos to get out of the way as timetabled. Good running was marred at Gerrard's Cross, High Wycombe, and Bicester North by the failure to clear the main line promptly, but then the railways would run alot more smoothly if passengers wouldn't insist on getting off the trains at their stations... Nevertheless it does appear that the Mainline timetable is very tightly planned and thus open to delays very easily.
Alas, my own journey was marred by the failure of the WiFi altogether on this set though at least the power points were working. No catering trolley of course, being an evening service. One wonders how the Silver trains are doing in this respect.
Arrival into Birmingham Moor Street was 4 minutes down (94 mins for the journey as opposed to the booked 90) BUT of course arrival into Snow Hill was on time as the 16.30 is booked to stand for 4 mins at Moor Street!
Lots of quibbles I know but overall Mainline is going to be worth it, I'm sure
Tuesday, 6 September 2011
Chiltern Railways Mainline day 1 part 2
Declaration of interest: as with part 1 of this blog posting, the journey back from London Marylebone on the 1807 yesterday was courtesy of Chiltern Railways BUT I did pay for the pot of tea (see below) at £1.60...
Among the guests of Adrian Shooter on the journey up to London were fellow tweeters Phil Tonks (@philtonks2) and Chris Bates (@chrisbates3). Phil recorded an interview with Thomas Abelman (Chiltern's Marketing Director) for his next Bridge Radio show so had to retire to the pub to recuperate but Chris and I found ourselves, along with 2 others, in the Business Zone of the 1807 'Silver' train from Marylebone back to Moor Street...
Though the 1807 is a 'Silver' train with first stop Warwick Parkway, it actually runs through to Kidderminster in a time of 140mins. Presumably Chiltern are testing the market for fast trains from the Worcestershire hinterland yet to do so, they have had to cut out the Dorridge stop... and the Leamington stop...Who would be a train / business planner!
Back to the journey... the Business Zone branding is interesting as the Antimacassars simply state 'Business Zone' with the word Mainline underneath, and the carriage window destination stickers simply say 'Mainline.
Clearly there is a more spacious feel to a carriage with 2 + 1 tables as opposed to the 2+2 arrangement of Standard Class, and it is nice to see the tables set with cups and saucers and to have a pot of tea served with real milk. BUT is it really necessary to charge £1.60 even if that is comparatively good value (Chiltern are adamant that their market research shows that business people do not want 'free' items pushing up the basic fare).
As a business person, I was very disappointed that the power sockets weren't working (but at least Chiltern staff try to do something about it unlike other TOC staff) and that the free WiFi was very intermittent. No doubt both matters will improve....
More worryingly for Chiltern is the lack of awareness of the business zone - no indication at Marylebone as we boarded the train, no announcements about upgrading, and a lack of clarity as to the role of the dedicated host. So I was the only occupant of the carriage from Warwick Parkway! All first day teething issues one hopes.
Talking of teething problems, the new signalling around Northolt Junction played up and we lost 15mins on the journey overall. Still, the travellers waiting at Moor Street for a train to Rowley Regis were delighted to try out the Business Zone for their trip (though the catering staff leave the train at Moor Street).
Finally, Chris Bates is the Chair of the Cherwell Valley Rail Users Group and sits on Chiltern's passenger board. He is in regular contact with Chiltern's management team, and clearly has views on how Chiltern should look after all their customers. To know more, contact him through his Tweeter feed or email him on chrisjbates AT btinternet.com
Among the guests of Adrian Shooter on the journey up to London were fellow tweeters Phil Tonks (@philtonks2) and Chris Bates (@chrisbates3). Phil recorded an interview with Thomas Abelman (Chiltern's Marketing Director) for his next Bridge Radio show so had to retire to the pub to recuperate but Chris and I found ourselves, along with 2 others, in the Business Zone of the 1807 'Silver' train from Marylebone back to Moor Street...
Though the 1807 is a 'Silver' train with first stop Warwick Parkway, it actually runs through to Kidderminster in a time of 140mins. Presumably Chiltern are testing the market for fast trains from the Worcestershire hinterland yet to do so, they have had to cut out the Dorridge stop... and the Leamington stop...Who would be a train / business planner!
Back to the journey... the Business Zone branding is interesting as the Antimacassars simply state 'Business Zone' with the word Mainline underneath, and the carriage window destination stickers simply say 'Mainline.
Clearly there is a more spacious feel to a carriage with 2 + 1 tables as opposed to the 2+2 arrangement of Standard Class, and it is nice to see the tables set with cups and saucers and to have a pot of tea served with real milk. BUT is it really necessary to charge £1.60 even if that is comparatively good value (Chiltern are adamant that their market research shows that business people do not want 'free' items pushing up the basic fare).
As a business person, I was very disappointed that the power sockets weren't working (but at least Chiltern staff try to do something about it unlike other TOC staff) and that the free WiFi was very intermittent. No doubt both matters will improve....
More worryingly for Chiltern is the lack of awareness of the business zone - no indication at Marylebone as we boarded the train, no announcements about upgrading, and a lack of clarity as to the role of the dedicated host. So I was the only occupant of the carriage from Warwick Parkway! All first day teething issues one hopes.
Talking of teething problems, the new signalling around Northolt Junction played up and we lost 15mins on the journey overall. Still, the travellers waiting at Moor Street for a train to Rowley Regis were delighted to try out the Business Zone for their trip (though the catering staff leave the train at Moor Street).
Finally, Chris Bates is the Chair of the Cherwell Valley Rail Users Group and sits on Chiltern's passenger board. He is in regular contact with Chiltern's management team, and clearly has views on how Chiltern should look after all their customers. To know more, contact him through his Tweeter feed or email him on chrisjbates AT btinternet.com
Chiltern Railways Mainline - day 1 part 1
Declaration of interest: up to now, my blog posts have arisen from travel paid for by myself. However, today's parts 1 and 2 come courtesy of Chiltern Railways who were kind enough to invite me to join Adrian Shooter's afternoon tea party on the 1555 departure from Birmingham Moor Street yesterday, and then gave me a pass for the 1807 return journey from London Marylebone...
The 1555 is a Mainline 'Silver' train (ie loco-hauled Mark 3 coaches). Afternoon was served in Coach B, with Coach A (the Business Zone) being used by the caterers and Coaches C - E left to the actual fare-paying passengers...
The train set had been fully refurbished in terms of branding and livery but, of course, had not yet had it's slam doors replaced. Apart from the amazing comfort and facilities of this standard class as compared to almost every other offering on the Birmingham to London route, the big plus is the smooth and quiet ride of the stock.
Adrian Shooter started proceedings with a speech of welcome which touched upon the achievement to date of Evergreen 3 as shown by Mainline and on Chiltern's plans for the future. Then it was down to the food - excellent - and conversation with Chiltern senior staff. Everything was up for discussion, ranging from the internal signage to the 'Expresso Bar' to the development of business cases for Oxford and Stratford to the iniquities (my word) of the way that information about Birmingham to London services is made available by certain parties within the railway industry.
Clearly, Chiltern are determined to make further inroads into the Birmingham to London and London to Birmingham travel flows. Good news for those of us who actually like competition within the rail industry!
My thanks to Emma (the wonderful Chiltern Tweeter) and Nicola (the marvellous Chiltern press officer) for their hospitality, and good luck to the team behind Mainline (dare I say you might need it). Businesses in Birmingham wanting to develop their travel portfolio for trips to London should contact John-James Davidson at Moor Street (John.davidson@chilternrailways.co.uk)
The 1555 is a Mainline 'Silver' train (ie loco-hauled Mark 3 coaches). Afternoon was served in Coach B, with Coach A (the Business Zone) being used by the caterers and Coaches C - E left to the actual fare-paying passengers...
The train set had been fully refurbished in terms of branding and livery but, of course, had not yet had it's slam doors replaced. Apart from the amazing comfort and facilities of this standard class as compared to almost every other offering on the Birmingham to London route, the big plus is the smooth and quiet ride of the stock.
Adrian Shooter started proceedings with a speech of welcome which touched upon the achievement to date of Evergreen 3 as shown by Mainline and on Chiltern's plans for the future. Then it was down to the food - excellent - and conversation with Chiltern senior staff. Everything was up for discussion, ranging from the internal signage to the 'Expresso Bar' to the development of business cases for Oxford and Stratford to the iniquities (my word) of the way that information about Birmingham to London services is made available by certain parties within the railway industry.
Clearly, Chiltern are determined to make further inroads into the Birmingham to London and London to Birmingham travel flows. Good news for those of us who actually like competition within the rail industry!
My thanks to Emma (the wonderful Chiltern Tweeter) and Nicola (the marvellous Chiltern press officer) for their hospitality, and good luck to the team behind Mainline (dare I say you might need it). Businesses in Birmingham wanting to develop their travel portfolio for trips to London should contact John-James Davidson at Moor Street (John.davidson@chilternrailways.co.uk)
Virgin strike back...
Virgin Trains are busy reminding everyone that they are still the fastest route from Birmingham to London with a Fly Virgin Trains promotion over the next two weeks. An associated Facebook competition is offering a trip to London for two nights for two... Clear where Virgin think the market flow is!
Monday, 5 September 2011
Chiltern Mainline £1 promotion
Today's launch of Chiltern Mainline has been accompanied by much marketing activity in Birmingham. The Metro had a four page wrapround, and leafleters were out in force in Birmingham city centre. The main thrust of the promotion is a "Try us for £1" offer redeemable through onepoundpromotion.co.uk (Metro) or mainlineforapound.co.uk (leaflet). Both addresses actually resolve to http://chilternrailways.co.uk/%C2%A31offer
The offer lasts until 19th September, and, as at Monday lunchtime, there was generous availability of the £1 tickets... However, unlike the LondonMidland promotion, these are Advance tickets which can only be used on the booked trains.
Even so, worth a shot!
The offer lasts until 19th September, and, as at Monday lunchtime, there was generous availability of the £1 tickets... However, unlike the LondonMidland promotion, these are Advance tickets which can only be used on the booked trains.
Even so, worth a shot!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)