Wednesday, 5 October 2011

OK Chiltern - part 2


Repeated Declaration of Interest: the basic fares for today's journeys were covered by a Chitern Railways' Free Travel Pass. I paid for the Business Zone supplements on the 0655, 0837, and 1807 journeys, and for the food consumed...

Left Banbury on the 1430 Silver Set to Moor Street. Smiling catering host happily sold me a coffee and cookie - very nice. Declassified Business Zone virtually empty... Rather warm but still a good working environment. On time arrival into Moor Street.

This rather warm set formed the 1555 back to London. Only two taking advantage of the £10 upgrade, though 4 overseas visitors did cough up at Bicester North (perhaps Chiltern should do a special BZ ticket to Bicester Village???). Free tea served promptly, and top up offered during journey. What can one say: the experience is consistent but not sold... Business Zone as travelling office space anyone?

Final turn round at Marylebone. Two of us in the BZ to Moor Street. Offered tea again (and top up later) BUT only hot food was the bacon / sausage roll options. Sorry Phil Tonks, but these are morning offerings - a panini would have been welcome tonight! Set by now very warm, as shown by the melting KitKat that I bought from the 'Expresso Bar'. Still, running to time; quiet environment; reasonable food - what more could I ask for?

My fear is that Chiltern are locked into the WSMR syndrome. Great product but the message isn't getting across to the target audience... Barry Doe's points are well made.

OK Chiltern, why don't you publicise the Business Zone?


Declaration of Interest: the basic fares for today's journeys were covered by a Chitern Railways' Free Travel Pass. I paid for the Business Zone supplements on the 0655, 0837, and 1807 journeys, and for the food consumed...

In today's Rail magazine, Barry Doe lambasts Chiltern for the marketing effort put into the Business Zone, and more generally for the timetable publicity published for Chiltern Mainline. Seeing this article on Saturday, and having a personal reason to be travelling to / from Banbury over lunchtime, I decided that it was about time that I experienced Chiltern Mainline 'for real'...

The 0655 Silver train set was sitting in Platform 3 as I arrived in Moor Street at 0645; not that the main concourse departure board was showing it, though the one beyond the barriers was. No barrier staff and no announcement, either on the station or on the train prior to departure. Clearly, Chiltern staff are like the rest of us: slow to get going in the morning!

I had taken the trouble to buy my supplement the day before at the Moor Street ticket office and so expected to find my seat reserved. Alas not as no reservation tickets were in evidence. Not that this really mattered as there were two of us in the Business Zone upon departure... (a further person joined at Solihull, and 5 more at Warwick Parkway).

First pleasant surprise of the day: free tea / coffee offered on departure, along with a copy of the Birmingham Mail or Financial Times. So much for the 'no extras' policy - though of course Chiltern publicity hasn't caught up with this change. Bacon Roll at £3 was tasty and, as promised, freshly made, and, of course, the tea comes in a pot with real milk and large cups.

Working power points and free working wi-fi along with plenty of space made it an ideal laptop working environment; and, as ever, the Chiltern staff were a delight - a refill of the tea pot was no problem (Virgin Trains please note).

Minor niggles... why did the magazine rack have out-of-date Economists? And did I really hear the Train Manager refer to the Business Zone as First Class???

Straight back on the 0837 which was formed of the Silver Set which had worked the 0619 up from Moor Street. This time there were 8 of us taking advantage of the £10 supplementary fare (what a bargain Marylebone - Moor Street is at £45 Business Zone return - pity the timings aren't business friendly, and, of
course, the services terminate and start from Moor Street, not the Birmingham Business District station of Snow Hill).

Another friendly business zone host and attentive service. Sausage roll at £3 was enjoyable too. As above, working wi-fi and power points meant that the Zone was a hive of purposeful activity...

Time to stretch my legs at Moor Street before rejoining the set which was working back as the 1055. No supplement on this service as officially it doesn't have a business zone, but the on board catering crew still came round to see if anything was needed. Had to pay for my coffee! Very quiet however as of course most Chiltern Railway passengers think 'standard class' and Chiltern don't really explain when BZ carriages aren't (as it were). Point to Barry here...

Off at Banbury. All three journeys roughly to time though the 0655 did suffer an emergency brake application outside High Wycombe, and the 1055 lost time at Warwick Parkway due to signalling problems. Did I mention that the toilet was spotless?

To be continued

Sunday, 25 September 2011

Two Together Railcard

Rail users in the West Midlands are being used to test a new Railcard - Two Together - which, for an annual fee of £28 gives 1/3rd off Standard and First Anytime, Off-Peak, and Advance tickets for the two over-16s named (and pictured) on the card.

To qualify, one of the two named individuals must have an address in the B, CV, DY, WS, or WW postcode districts. One key restriction: the discounted tickets bought with this railcard are NOT valid for travel between 04:30 and 09:30 Monday to Friday. 

Using the railcard will allow Virgin passengers to travel together with a discount on the 0930  and 0950 Pendolinos Birmingham to London using Anytime tickets BUT NOT off-peak tickets. It seems that Virgin are not treating this railcard like the long-established ones which, of course, give off-peak travel on any Virgin service... However, at least you can apply the discount when booking online with Virgin which is more than can be done currently on both LondonMidland and Chiltern Railways sites. Come on guys, keep up!

Sorry, I still don't 'get' HS2...

On Friday, over a very enjoyable lunch, I had an illuminating conversation with a professional railway operator on the subject of HS2. I admitted that I failed to understand why the railway companies were so keen on HS2 when it was so costly, so distant in timescale, and seemed to me to offer so few tangible benefits.

Very kindly, he explained that the core of the railway's enthusiasm for HS2 was the fact that it provided an answer to the current and projected WCML congestion south of Rugby. There was, he avowed, no other way forward. Pressing him further, he seemed to suggest that the railways were still scarred by the WCML Route Modernisations of the 1960s and 70s and by the WCML Upgrade of the 'Noughties' and that noone wanted to go through that again. Finally, he suggested that Birmingham was an irrelevance as a destination and that the prize was capacity relief not end-to-end journey times.

Whilst the above reasons for HS2 (which are my interpretations of the conversation) are no doubt valid they still do not answer my key objections...
1) Why are we planning for 2026 using 2010 assumptions about growth in railway traffic when technological, especially communication, developments are now happening at such a pace that we can't foresee how then worlds of work and leisure will look in 2026.
2) Why are we assuming that these same technological and communication developments won't  increase line capacity dramatically through better signalling control, route planning, and rolling stock capabilities
3) Why are billions to be spent when millions will bring immediate capacity enhancements at key pinch points on the WCML and on the alternative freight and passenger routes (Chiltern Mainline showing the way here).
4) Why the stubborn belief that the extra speed will benefit Birmingham rather than suck yet more jobs down to London as Birmingham becomes a dormitory city for the capital.

Sorry, HS2 seems to me to be simply one of those grandiose schemes dreamt up and supported by those who know that they won't have to pick up the bill as they will have all retired by 2026!

Still a Virgin? Take two..

Friday saw more lunch / evening engagements in London so another chance to check out Virgin's Pendolino service from Birmingham New Street to London Euston and return.

Success this time in making the 10.10 train. This service starts at Wolverhampton so was fairly busy on arrival in Birmingham. Plenty of seats to be had however, even though it is the first 'off-peak' service of the day. I had a reserved seat in Coach A but it wasn't a table as I had requested... fortunately, a pair of fellow passengers who were seated at a table took pity on me and moved. Memo to Virgin - if the power point option is NOT checked on the reservation system, please do not allocate table seats when they are not needed!

Departure on time, this time without the complete litany of announcements that make Virgin journeys so annoying - still bad enough with just the automated ones however. Shop announcement made upon departure and cappuccino and flapjack secured once again.

The socket at the table was working BUT the WiFi wasn't (third time unlucky in my case). A tweet to @virgintrains gained the standard response of the 0845 number. When I asked for the landline number, it couldn't be provided (reminder, it is 0207 0966966 and choose Option 3) but then a response came that the service was down altogether. So at least the Twitter approach is worth pursuing.

Arrival into London Euston was on time BUT yet again no ticket check at any point on the journey. Revenue protection isn't one of Virgin's strong points...

However... on the way back, the barrier at Euston's platform 5 was actually manned and my ticket for the 20.23 properly checked. Amazing!

For what seemed to be a busy train, Coach E was surprisingly empty and I could have got a table seat if I had tried hard enough (was using Coach E as the reservation system claimed that I couldn't reserve a seat on this service - was it full or do Virgin not do reservations on Friday night services?). Even better, WiFi was working though it did take some coaxing into life. Of course, it cost me £4 for an hour but at least the download speed was good. Interestingly, I could only connect one device at a time - something that isn't the case on the equivalent free service on Chiltern.

Coach E sits next to First Class coach G in the Pendolino formation. Stretching my legs, I was surprised to find a completely empty Coach G. Clearly Virgin are not doing a particularly good job at selling off  First Class seats. Alas, I am old enough to remember BR's experiment with 'Silver Standard' and wonder if Virgin aren't missing a trick here. Why not sell off the Coach G seats on the train to walk-on fare passengers as at the weekend on the basis of availability (using the reservation system to fill Coaches J-H)? I would happily have paid £10 extra for the use of a table and some light refreshments served at my seat...

Arrival into New Street on time, so another 'as it should happen' Virgin journey. I just wish they would do more to make the experience enjoyable but then the Company is very successful as it is so why bother, I suppose...

Finally, for both of my recent return trips, I have been using the web-based walk-on fares which allow mix and match between off-peak (out after 10am) and super off-peak (return after 8pm) fares, meaning  have done both journeys for £34.40 each time. Alas, it is likely that Virgin will withdraw the super off-peak fare from the 9th October, so be quick if you want to take advantage of this saving.

Thursday, 15 September 2011

Still a Virgin? Taking the Pendolinos on the New Street to Euston run

Regular readers of my blog will know that I favour Chiltern for Birmingham to London travel as I find that the working environment is very pleasant. If I travel Virgin, I try to book in advance in First Class in an effort to replicate this Chiltern experience at not too great a cost.

Alas, however, there are days when both timing and cost win out and I have to travel Virgin Standard using walk-on fares. Yesterday was such a day.

I had hoped to catch the 10.10 Pendolino service from Birmingham New Street to London Euston, but, as I feared, was delayed by work and got away only in time for the 10.30. This didn't matter as I was using walk-on tickets, and, of course Virgin's VHF timetable and fast journey time gave me plenty of leeway.

The 10.30 was sitting in Platform 5 but was still downloading the reservation details when I turned up at 10.20. There followed a 5 minute wait until I could be sure of my table seat in Coach A - why can't Virgin download this information more quickly? Settled in my table and plugged my laptop in - power on! Tried to attach to the WiFi - not available... (see my post http://birmingham2london.blogspot.com/2011/09/virgin-trains-wifi-service.html). Quiet coach A quiet in terms of passengers too as was Coach B - amused to see the 'reservation' syndrome in Coach C however... you don't have to sit in the reserved seat if you're travelling on an Advance ticket!

Lots of announcements from both the automated voices and the train manager before and after the on-time departure - you certainly get information overload from Virgin - followed by a shop announcement. Went to the  Shop for a cappuccino and flapjack - very nice and not too expensive... No water to wash hands in the Coach A toilet however.

Good journey and arrival in Euston on time. However, no ticket check at any point on my journey  - don't Virgin care about revenue protection?

Coming back, I joined the fairly busy and slightly delayed 20.23. Coach A was relatively quiet and a table was free. Power BUT no WiFi again... Seemed to be fewer announcements but perhaps I was just inured to them... Train manager checked tickets after Milton Keynes but, of course, couldn't help with the non-working WiFi. No water to wash hands in the Coach A toilet again...

Arrival into New Street on time.

Overall, a typically efficient Virgin experience which could be better but which achieves in terms of timing what it promises. Compared to Chiltern and LondonMidland - see comparison chart for alternatives for yesterday's journeys - it is more expensive and lacks 'ambience' in Standard Class but sometimes speed will out! So, am I still a Virgin? Yes, when it suits me...


Virgin Trains WiFi service

Yesterday, I travelled to & from London on the Virgin Pendolino service from Birmingham to London and return (of which more later).

In both directions, I was frustrated by the inability to connect to the WiFi whilst sitting in Standard Class Coach A. On the way down, I complained via Twitter and did get a response back from @virgintrains (on the way back, the team had gone home...) but alas it was pretty useless, suggesting that I contact an 0845 number  (from a mobile phone in the Quiet Zone - I don't think so).

This morning, however, I have had a very useful conversation with the third-party company (Nomad) that provides the support desk for the T-Mobile WiFi provided on Virgin's trains... Apparently, yesterday, two Pendolino sets did have WiFi with problems (now rectified). More usefully, I have been given the more customer friendly way of contacting them...

Instead of ringing 0845 287 2149 - which on my Orange mobile business account would have cost me 12.4p / minute - ring 0207 0966966 and choose Option 3. The team will be able to check whether the WiFi is in fact available, and can provide the direct IP address of the server to enter into the browser URL bar.

Better still, if, like me, you travel in the Quiet Zone in order to be able to work, they will take your mobile number and provide support by text...

NOW, why can't Virgin Customer Support be this helpful AND, more importantly, why can't the Train Managers carry this information with them???