Friday, 4 November 2011

iPhone Apps: Chiltern Railways

The iPhone App from Chiltern Railways has been available for a year now, and has developed into an online ticket buying and real-time information application. Indeed, the App won Most Effective ticketing solution at the Mobile Marketing Awards held on 3 November.

The Chiltern information page on the App states:

  • Quick tickets sent to your phone
  • No account login required
  • No booking or card fees
  • Save favourite journeys
  • View train times
  • Buy tickets to anywhere in the UK
What it doesn't mention (tut tut Chiltern - how about keeping your web site bang up-to-date?) is that the latest iteration, V1.07.62, also offers live train arrival / departure times for any station in the UK.

So, the good things...
  1. Very clear train times finder with the ability to buy tickets easily
  2. mTickets available for certain Chiltern journeys making it easy to travel without hassle
  3. Live departure and arrivals
The not so good...
  1. Support is via a 0845 number
  2. External links are all web based
  3. mTickets availability very limited a present
And the missing..
  1. Just look at what LondonMidland have managed to offer on their App!

iPhone Apps: LondonMidland

So now we have a full set of iPhone Apps from the Birmingham to London route operators. How do they compare.

LondonMidland

This is the new kid on the block, having been launched on Tuesday (1 November). Naturally it is free and its description page claims it offers:


  • Plan your London Midland journey with the journey planner
  • Add multiple station favourites, making it easier to plan frequent journeys
  • Email, SMS or print your journey plan details
  • Disruption information giving you alternative journey options if required
  • One touch access to live departures and arrival at all London Midland stations, with platform information (where available) and live train progress
  • ‘Next Train Home’ feature automatically finds the nearest train station and searches trains times to get you home
  • View timetables even without an Internet connection, specifically designed to fit your mobile screen
  • View our @LondonMidland Twitter feed without leaving the app, whether you follow us or not
  • Purchase car parking directly from the app via SMS or phone (where available)
  • Submit your ‘Delay Repay’ form directly from the app
  • Contact Customer Services directly from the app
As with most iPhone Apps, it works best with either 3G or WiFi enabled. It's opening screen displays a top banner, a Live Departures and arrivals panel, the Journey Planner, an Info panel, a Contact us panel, and a Settings panel.This last panel allows a 'home station' to be set, features in the Journey Planner to be changed, the Interface to be set at 'Start at home screen', distance to be set in either miles or kilometres, and Help and Support to be contacted.

All the panels seem to work fine. 

  • The Live Departures and arrivals, and the journey planner are not LondonMidland specific though the 'Nearest' / Favourite / Recent buttons will presumably have that effect for regular LM travellers. 
  • The Info panel as a 'Disruption information' live feed as well as live feeds from London Underground (actually TfL) and the @londonmidland Twitter feed. Alas, the TfL feed takes you out of the App and into Safari. Timetables can be downloaded. Car parking can be purchased through a web link (a nice feature is to show which stations offer FREE parking), and a Delay Repay form can be completed and sent to LM via email (again, a nice touch is the ability to add a photo of the ticket).
  • Contact us gives an email option BUT more usefully the landline number (0121 634 2040) for LM's Customer Relations Team (definite brownie point for NOT hiding behind a 0845 number).

So, all good stuff, but you can't book tickets! V2 beckons I reckon




Chiltern Mainline on a Clubman

In all the 'excitement' about the Business Zone provision and future Silver Set deployment, it is easy to forget that the bulk of the Chiltern Mainline timetable is run day-in day-out by the highly successful Class 168 Clubman DMUs. As regular readers of this blog will know, I am a fan of the Clubmans (see Thursday 18th Nov 2010 et passim...) but for various reasons I haven't actually used them for sometime. However, a trip to London on Wednesday allowed me to rectify this omission.

Thanks to the timings of my trip, I was able to buy a £25 super off-peak return from Birmingham Moor Street, and join the 11.55 Mainline service which was sitting waiting in Platform 4 having worked the 9.37 down from London Marylebone. This walk-on fare is a veritable bargain when you consider the timings now available (97 mins) along with the availability of tables, power points, and FREE WiFi. Just a pity that Chiltern can't make the timetable work to allow the service to start at Birmingham Snow Hill and tap the business market more effectively.

The loading of the train was only reasonable on departure from Moor Street but of course this meant that obtaining a table to myself and laptop proved no problem. In fact, I wasn't joined at my table until the final stop at Banbury, though the train had filled nicely at the previous stops.

As I have said many times, Chiltern simply deliver... the catering trolley came round, tickets were checked after Leamington, WiFi and power points worked, the toilets were clean and worked, and I had an hour-and-a-half of uninterrupted working time. What more could Chiltern offer me???

Well, an better return evening service would be a start. The first train back from London Marylebone for Super Off-Peak ticket holders is the 19.15 which for some reason has a stop at Bicester North with a consequent 109 minute scheduled journey time. Further, as has been detailed on Chiltern's Twitter feed ad nauseum it is a very busy train. On Wednesday, it left Marylebone full and standing to Bicester.

The problems above are compounded by the fact that the Mainline timetable NORTH doesn't work. As I had experienced before, a late running High Wycombe train brought the 19.15 to a dead halt at Gerrard's Cross and then slow running ensued until the train in front cleared at High Wycombe. The consequence: at Aynho Junction we lost our path to a FREIGHT train (Network Rail come on...), and then at Dorridge were looped to allow a CrossCountry to overtake. 'Mainline' - I don't think so as we limped into Moor Street 16 minutes late (would Virgin put up with such behaviour by Network Rail signallers?). AND, of course, Chiltern don't offer catering on Clubman evening services back to Birmingham...

So although the fare is amazing value and Clubman's are great trains on which to travel - WiFi etc all fine on the 19.15 - Chiltern clearly have a long way to go before they can convince the powers that be that they do actually offer a MAINLINE service to Birmingham. Pity...

Saturday, 29 October 2011

Lunch with Adrian Shooter (well, almost...)

Declaration of interest: I was a guest of Modern Railways at this 4th Friday Club meeting

I was lucky enough to be at September's 4th Friday Club lunch to hear Adrian Shooter give a valedictory speech on his time as a railwayman. Now, I am not a journalist and didn't take notes at the time so the following reportage is very much my impressions and interpretations of what he said. (The full text of Adrian's address can be found in the November 2011 issue of Modern Railways)

Adrian's speech was really a lesson in railway history and in what the present day companies can learn from the almost 200 years of railway development in the UK. Starting by claiming George Stephenson as a forebear (on his mother's side), his first point was that by the 1860s almost all of the core network of rail routes in this country had been laid down and that, by and large, they served traffic flows to and from London. (later on in his speech, he praised Beeching for wanting to par back the railways to this core network). Naturally, I wonder if he was being post-ironic in this assertion as of course a key element of the Chiltern Railways route was not laid down until the first decade of the last century - 40 years later than the 1860s 'core' point...

Moving onto the war years, First and Second, he drew out the obvious point that once politicians and civil servants get involved in a business, they are loath not to continue to meddle in that business... he also bemoaned the fact that no government was prepared to give the Railways a 'fair deal' in terms of regulation and tariffs despite the fact that the (road) competion was unfettered.

Post Second World War, he dismissed Nationalisation as being politically motivated, and the 1955 Rail Modernisation plan as a shambles. As noted above, he loved the Beeching Report, not only for the paring back but also for the vision of how the railways could be (container trains, inter-city etc). Indeed, it was the Beeching Report which inspired him to join the railways as a career.

As an engineer, he clearly has a soft spot for the (LMS) Derby engineers from whom he seems to have learnt much. Also praised were British Rail Chairmen Sir Peter Parker and Sir Bob Reid, the latter especially lauded for letting his Sector Managers get on with it prior to privatisation...

Ah yes, privatisation: John Major was given credit for the vision of the privatised railway (something that famously even Mrs T. couldn't face doing) but 'bottled out' (my phrase) of the correct implementation. The Bill itself was a hodge-podge of inserts from interested parties which could have been made to work if the BR Board had engaged in the process. As it turned out, Adrian proved to be one of the drafters of the legalisation along with other senior BR managers working in cahoots with the Dept. of Transport's civil servants....

The story of M40 Trains and Chiltern Railways is well covered in Hugh Jones' book (The Chiltern Railways Story). What I hadn't realised fully was the risk that Adrian and his fellow-directors took with their own money when the 22 year franchise was offered by Sir Alistair Morton of the SRA. No wonder he has been so passionate about making Chiltern work.

Skipping to the present day, it seems clear that he has little time for those who do not add 'net value' to the railways (fill in your own blanks), and that he has an especial dislike of the lawyers used by civil servants to cover their backsides...

Finally, he ended with this pithy summary of the McNulty Report. The accountant in McNulty discovered that Railways have largely fixed costs. Passenger usage has almost doubled therefore unit costs should have halved... oh s**t. The conclusion that this led McNulty to has mysteriously not seen the light of day!

Passionate, opinionated, involved - will we see his like again in the modern rail industry?

Tuesday, 25 October 2011

LondonMidland's Great Escape: good value but too successful (part 2)?

LondonMidland's Great Escape promotion has interesting set of restrictions out of Euston Monday to Friday. Basically, First Class is not restricted, whilst Standard Class can travel between 4pm and 7pm by buying an additional £5 easement before the journey back...

As it happened, I was joining the 1913 departure from Euston's Platform 17. This is an 8-car Desiro formation, the front four carriages of which go forward from Northampton to Birmingham - a fact that was clearly marked on each of the two 4-car sets. The timing of this service is good (2 hours 3 minutes), making it almost as fast as the equivalent Chiltern service. However, just as Chiltern are finding it difficult to manage off-peak demand back from Marylebone, so LondonMidland have produced a combination of circumstances which meant the train was completely full and standing when I arrived to join it 5 minutes before departure.

The situation was exacerbated by a lack of revenue control, and the non-appearance of the train manager whose only contribution was to urge passengers to move down the already full train in the hope of finding a seat. Clearly an own goal by LondonMidland who risk alienating their First Class commuters in the pursuit of the family off-peak market (it subsequently transpired that one family in the Birmingham First Class compartment were travelling on Standard Class Great Escape tickets, but it would take a brave train manager to ask a mother to make her children stand...).

Fortunately from my point of view I was able to get a First Class seat after the Leighton Buzzard stop, and, I have to say, that it is perfectly possible to work on a laptop in the airline style seats (at least there are power points). First Class remained full until Birmingham, though clearly not all were First Class ticket holders, and Standard Class did not become comfortable until Coventry.

No ticket checks (of course??) until after Birmingham International - LondonMidland really need to get their customer facing staff more focused. Mind you, one suspects that the staff feel dumped on in such situations.

Overall, would I use the Great Escape again? £20 walk-on with voucher compares to £25 walk-on Standard with Chiltern and £44.30 walk-on Standard for Virgin (admittedly, both would be more expensive for a 4pm to 7pm departure). For both companies, their standard fare offers so much more than LondonMidland's First Class fare - so, sorry LM, but you're only occasionally going to persuade me to use you after yesterday's experience.

LondonMidland's Great Escape: good value but too successful (part 1)?

This week and next, LondonMidland are offering off-peak day ranger tickets at £10 standard class and £20 First Class through the Great Escape promotion. Effectively, these are walk-on fares but quota-limited through the need to download a voucher to qualify. Off-peak for this promotion starts at 9.30am Monday to Friday though there are easements (no restriction Saturday / Sunday), and returning from London Monday to Friday also has some restrictions (see part 2).

However, unlike previous promotions on these lines from LondonMidland, there is no easement on the Birmingham to London route so I duly rolled up with my voucher for the 9.33 Desiro to Euston. First indications seemed to indicate that the First Class compartment would be quiet as the ticket clerk at Victoria Square said that mine was the first one he had had to do. However, joining the train showed that many were also taking advantage of the promotion...

Secured a table with working power point for my laptop and settled down to work (one of the 'advantages' of LondonMidland could be said to be the lack of WiFi which means there is no temptation to do email...). Soon joined by a family - two adults and a young girl - who were off to the Tower for the day (using the 2 for 1 attraction vouchers). Clearly the 2 hour 16 minute journey time did not outweigh the promotional savings...

The 4 car Desiro left New Street fairly full (including in First Class), and continued to pick up passengers through to Coventry. Have to admit that I was still thinking that after Coventry matters would quieten but the crowds at Coventry and Rugby disabused me. By Northampton, despite the addition of a 4 car set from Crewe, it was standing room only in Standard, and full in First Class... Fortunately, the train calls only at Milton Keynes and Watford Junction after Northampton so matter got only marginally worse.

So, what was good and what was bad? Well, the Desiros ride well and given that the seating is commuter style are relatively comfortable. However, apparently the toilets were 'disgusting' in the set that left Birmingham - the description of the mother of the family - though to be fair the train manager did apologise and suggest that the 17 (17!) minute layover at Northampton would give ample time for a comfort stop... Time keeping was ok but that wait at Northampton.... LondonMidland could rival Chiltern times if there was more flexibility in the timetable pathing (I know, I know, that's why we need HS2 - but that won't answer the immediate need...). The usual bug bear: the train manager didn't appear aside from one ticket inspection nearing Coventry. I know it must be awful to be abused by standing passengers when there is little that you can do BUT train managers are the public face of the company so should at least show that they care...

Finally, a matter outside of LondonMidland's control... We were brought into Platform 17 at Euston which, alas, is one of the ones with relatively poor access and exit. Yesterday, the exit situation was worsened by the loading of a Virgin service for which Virgin staff were actually checking tickets before passengers could join the train. Much grumbling about the delays that this caused as one of the two narrow exit ramps was effectively blocked. Not good customer care by Network Rail.


Thursday, 13 October 2011

Adrian Shooter wins Lifetime Achievement Award

Declaration of interest: last night I attended the Birmingham Post Business Awards 2011 dinner as a guest of Chiltern Railways.

The Highlight of the evening was undoubtedly the Lifetime Achievement Award presented to Chiltern Chairman Adrian Shooter 'for his services to the region for his part in developing Chiltern’s Birmingham to London rail link'. In his short acceptance speech, Adrian paid tribute to the support of his wife Barbara, to the dedication of the Chiltern Railways staff, and to the business people of Birmingham who had told him that they wanted an alternative route to London... A photo of Adrian and Barbara with the Award can be found here, his short acceptance speech can be heard here, and a short interview after the award here (starts at 3mins 40secs).

Chiltern Railways sponsored the Award for the Emerging Professional. A photo of the winner, Matt Taylor from Headline Communications with Chiltern MD Rob Brighouse can be found here.

Around the Chiltern table there was much talk of all that had been achieved and of all there is still to do. Chatham House rules prevent me from spilling all the beans but among the topics under discussion were

  • the Business Zone
  • Snow Hill station
  • the difficulty of meeting passenger aspirations when the passengers then fail to take up the offering (WSMR, and last year's Stratford-London RSC trains spring to mind)
  • focus groups - a tool for the young?
  • tender loving care for the commuters at the southern end of the Mainline...
  • simplified fares
  • the use of social media (take a bow Emma, Nicola and Jo)
  • the good and not so good points about the Virgin service
Not surprisingly, the Chiltern message continues to be: 'we are listening'. So continue to carp and praise, promote and criticise, using the tools available